← Back to blog

Percent Complete Accounting for Trade Subs: A Plain Guide

November 16, 2026
Percent Complete Accounting for Trade Subs: A Plain Guide

Percent complete accounting means you book revenue and profit as the work gets done, not when the job closes or when you send an invoice. For a trade sub, the math is simple: costs to date divided by total estimated cost gives percent complete, and percent complete times the contract gives earned revenue. The hard part is keeping the estimated cost honest every month and matching it to what you have billed. Get that right and you know which jobs are making money before they finish.

Subascent
See Job Performance Before Closeout
Subascent helps trade businesses bring job information together, so owners can track costs and understand which projects are making money.
Visit

TL;DR

  • Percent complete = costs to date ÷ total estimated cost at completion. Earned revenue = percent complete × the contract, including approved change orders.
  • Compare earned revenue to what you billed. Billed more than earned is overbilling (a liability). Billed less is underbilling (an asset, and a cash drain).
  • Your tax method and your financial statement method are separate questions. Many small subs can use completed-contract for taxes, but bonding and banking usually want percent complete.
  • QuickBooks does not run the calculation for you. Someone has to build the schedule and post the adjusting entry every month.
  • The number is only as good as your estimate to complete. Update it monthly, with input from the field.

Table of Contents

What percent complete accounting is

A trade job rarely starts and finishes in one month. A mechanical sub might spend eight months on a hospital wing. If you only count profit when the last invoice goes out, your books say you lost money for seven months and got rich in the eighth. Neither is true.

Percent complete (also called percentage of completion, or POC) fixes that. Each month you estimate how far along the job is and recognize that share of the contract as revenue, with the matching costs. Your income statement then follows the work.

The most common way to measure progress is the cost-to-cost method. You use dollars of cost spent against dollars of cost expected. It works well for subs because labor, material and sub costs are already coming through job costing.

The formula, with a masonry example

Here is a made-up job to walk through. A masonry sub has an $800,000 contract. The estimated total cost is $600,000, so the planned profit is $200,000 (25%). At the end of the month, $240,000 of cost has hit the job, and you have billed $350,000.

  1. Percent complete: $240,000 ÷ $600,000 = 40%
  2. Earned revenue: 40% × $800,000 = $320,000
  3. Gross profit to date: $320,000 − $240,000 = $80,000
  4. Over/under billing: $350,000 billed − $320,000 earned = $30,000 overbilled

The $30,000 is not profit. You collected it, but you still owe the work behind it. It sits on the balance sheet as a liability.

Why the denominator matters most

The bottom number is the total estimated cost at completion. That is costs to date plus your best estimate of what is left. It is not your original bid number.

Say the brick, scaffold and labor outlook worsens, and you now expect a $650,000 total cost. Same $240,000 spent:

  • Percent complete drops to 36.9%.
  • Earned revenue drops to about $295,385.
  • Estimated profit falls from $200,000 to $150,000.
  • You are now overbilled about $54,615.

The field did not do less work. The formula is telling you the job will make less money than you thought. A ServiceTitan-style example is not needed here: the same effect holds on any job, and it is why you update the estimate every month.

For a deeper look at forecasting that number, see our cost-to-complete forecasting template.

When a trade sub has to use it

There are two separate questions: taxes and financial statements.

Taxes. The IRS construction audit guide says IRC §460 generally requires percentage of completion for long-term contracts (IRS Construction Industry ATG). There is a small contractor exception. You can use completed-contract or another method if the contract is expected to finish within two years and your average gross receipts are under the threshold. That threshold is $32 million for tax year 2026, up from $31 million in 2025 (SDO CPA). Both tests have to be met. Most subs in the $500K to $15M range fall under it for tax purposes.

Financial statements. This is where percent complete shows up anyway. The IRS guide explains that GAAP strongly prefers percentage of completion, so statements prepared for bonding, banks or other reporting are almost always done that way (IRS Construction Industry ATG). If you want a bigger bonding line or a bank line of credit, your surety and lender will want a WIP schedule.

On the rulebook side, ASC 606 replaced the old construction-specific guidance for fiscal years starting after December 15, 2017, and uses a five-step model where revenue is recognized as you satisfy a performance obligation, measured by input or output methods (SDO CPA). Cost-to-cost is an input method. The mechanics for your job stay the same. Ask your CPA how it applies to your statements.

Tax thresholds change every year. Check the current revenue procedure with your CPA before you rely on a number.

Overbilling and underbilling, in plain terms

The whole point of the WIP schedule is the gap between what you earned and what you billed.

Earned vs. billedBalance sheetWhat it means for cash
OverbilledBilled more than earnedLiability (billings in excess of costs and earnings)You hold the customer's cash for work not yet done
UnderbilledEarned more than billedAsset (costs and earnings in excess of billings)You are financing the job yourself

Overbilling can help short-term cash, but it is not extra profit, because you still have future work and costs to cover (Bilotta CPAs). The CMAA's WIP guide goes further and says any overbilling should be backed by cash in the bank (CMAA). If you spent the overbilling on another job's payroll, you have a problem when this job needs its money.

Underbilling is the quieter killer. You have paid your crew, your supplier and your subs without invoicing for it. The CMAA calls underbillings uncommon and a reason for concern, since it can point to unapproved change order pricing or billing criteria not yet met (CMAA). Construction Cost Accounting's guide lists the usual causes: invoicing lag, light AIA progress billings and change orders performed before approval (Construction Cost Accounting).

A quick read on a plumbing example: a school job with a $250,000 contract, $200,000 of cost and a $225,000 estimate is about 88.9% complete, so about $222,000 is earned. If you have billed only $175,000, you are about $47,000 underbilled. That is cash you fronted.

Plumbing job earned revenue versus billed amount

If your underbillings keep growing, read our cash flow warning signs and our guide to progress claims. Pay apps that lag the work are the most common cause.

What to do with change orders

Change orders break percent complete faster than anything else. Two rules keep you clean.

Only signed change orders go into the contract value. Level Accounting Firm's WIP guide says only signed and approved change orders belong in the revised contract, and verbal changes are left out (Level Accounting Firm). Think of a change order as moving through four states: proposed, approved in writing, performed, billed. Raise the contract only at approval.

Unapproved work still costs money. The costs go into your estimate to complete. A public company's SEC-filed statement shows the common treatment: costs on unapproved change orders count as job costs as incurred, with no margin recognized until realization is probable (SEC filing). In plain terms: you eat the cost on your WIP schedule until the GC signs.

Example: on the masonry job above, the GC verbally asks for extra reinforced bond beam work. You do $30,000 of it. Costs go up, the contract does not, and percent complete rises with no new revenue. Your margin looks worse until the signed change order lands. That is exactly the signal you want. It tells you to chase the paper.

The fixes are mostly in the field and the office: get the field to flag extra work the day it starts, price it, and send it for signature. Our HVAC estimating workflow shows how to cut these surprises at the bid stage.

What to do with change orders

The monthly routine

A good WIP schedule is one row per job. Level Accounting Firm lays out the columns: original contract, approved change orders, revised contract, estimated total cost, costs incurred, percent complete, earned revenue, billed, over/under billing, cost to complete and estimated profit (Level Accounting Firm).

Do it in this order each month:

  1. Close the job cost. Make sure every timecard, material invoice and sub bill is coded to the job. Late costs make percent complete wrong.
  2. Ask the PM and foreman for cost to complete. Do not just subtract. Ask what is left in hours, material and sub work.
  3. Update the contract. Add signed change orders only.
  4. Calculate percent complete and earned revenue for each job.
  5. Compare to billings. Flag any job off by more than you are comfortable with.
  6. Post the adjusting entry. For underbillings, debit the asset account and credit revenue. For overbillings, debit revenue and credit the liability account. Reverse it at the start of next month so it does not double count.
  7. Read the result. Which jobs have fading margins? Which are overbilled and short on cash behind them?

Our piece on the five numbers to read first on a WIP report tells you where to look when you have 15 jobs on one page.

Setting up QuickBooks so it does not fight you

QuickBooks does not build a WIP schedule or run percent complete natively. Level Accounting Firm notes this for QuickBooks Online (Level Accounting Firm). You pull costs and billings by job into a spreadsheet and book the entry yourself. Intuit's own construction accounting guide covers the cost-to-cost formula and the over/under definitions, which is the same math as above (Intuit).

What makes that easier is a chart of accounts built for contracting. Northstar Financial's setup guide recommends:

  • Only two to four income accounts (for example contract revenue, service/T&M and other), not a new one for every trade or job type.
  • Retainage receivable and subcontractor retainage payable as their own accounts.
  • A WIP asset account for costs in excess of billings and a WIP liability account for billings in excess of costs.
  • A reconciliation where the sum of all job underbillings ties to the asset account and the overbillings tie to the liability account.

Source: Northstar Financial.

A few practical habits for subs:

  • Keep direct job costs (labor, material, equipment, subs) separate from overhead, so job margins are not muddied.
  • Track change orders as their own line on the job, so you can see approved versus pending at a glance.
  • Do not treat billings as revenue during the month. Your invoices are billings. Earned revenue is a month-end calculation.

For more on getting job costs right in the books, see QuickBooks for subcontractors: 3 fixes for job cost accuracy and job costing explained for trade contractors. If electrical is your trade, read electrical job costing mistakes.

Where forecasting software fits

The slow part of percent complete is not the division. It is gathering clean costs, a believable estimate to complete and a current contract value from three different places. By the time a spreadsheet reaches the owner, it can be weeks old.

A tool built for trade subs shortens that. When job costs, change orders, billing and field time live in one place and sync with QuickBooks, you can see cost to date, contract value and billed amount for each job without chasing paper. That is what the forecasting step needs. You still make the call on cost to complete. The software just stops you from making it with stale numbers.

Perspective

We have run trade jobs where the books looked fine and the bank account said otherwise. Almost every time, the cause was the same two things: costs entered late and change orders that never got signed.

Percent complete is not an accounting exercise for your CPA. It is the monthly check on whether a job is paying you. If you are overbilled, you are spending someone else's money. If you are underbilled, you are lending yours.

That is why we built Subascent around the sub's real workflow. Bids, jobs, change orders, daily field reports, crew time, invoicing and profit analytics sit together, with QuickBooks sync, so the numbers a WIP schedule needs are already in one place. Foremen get the free CrewTrack mobile app with the subscription, so time and field notes reach the office as they happen instead of at the end of the week.

Start with your three biggest jobs. Get the estimate to complete from the foreman, and the signed change orders from the PM. Then look at the gap between earned and billed. You will learn more in an hour than in a quarter of reading P&Ls.

Dave

Getting the numbers in one place

If your WIP lives in a spreadsheet and your job costs live in three other places, Subascent is built for that gap. It is job and bid management software for specialty trade subs, with change order workflows, daily field reporting, labor and crew tracking, QuickBooks sync and profit analytics. Plans are Starter at $49 per month ($490 per year), Scale at $99 per month ($990 per year) and Pro at $179 per month ($1,790 per year). PDF takeoff is a paid add-on at $99 per month. See plans and features or look at invoicing and financials.

Subascent

FAQ

Is percentage of completion still allowed?

Yes. It is the method tax law generally requires for long-term contracts, and GAAP strongly prefers it for financial statements (IRS Construction Industry ATG). Small contractors that meet the gross receipts and two-year tests can use another method for taxes. Confirm which applies to you with your CPA.

Is ASC 606 the same as percentage of completion?

Not exactly. ASC 606 is the broader revenue standard. It replaced the old construction-specific guidance and measures progress on a performance obligation with input or output methods (SDO CPA). Cost-to-cost is a common input method, so the monthly math you do looks the same.

What is the difference between overbilling and underbilling?

Overbilling means you billed more than the revenue you have earned. It is a liability. Underbilling means you earned more than you billed. It is an asset, and it usually means you are funding the job. A large, growing underbilling is an early cash flow warning (Construction Cost Accounting).

Can QuickBooks do percent complete accounting?

Not by itself. QuickBooks Online does not build the WIP report natively (Level Accounting Firm). You export job costs and billings, calculate percent complete and post an adjusting entry each month. A clean construction chart of accounts makes that entry and its reconciliation much simpler.

Sources